Your Cart is Empty

Grown Up Grilled Cheese with Green Hill & Thomasville Tomme

Grown Up Grilled Cheese with Green Hill & Thomasville Tomme

Grown Up Grilled Cheese with Green Hill & Thomasville Tomme

Serves: 4

Difficulty level: Easy-Moderate


    • 8 thick cut slices of your favorite bread
      • we prefer whole wheat or rye bread
    • 1 SGD Green Hill Cheese, sliced into ⅛” round slices
    • 12 ounces SGD Thomasville Tomme, rind removed and sliced into ⅛” strips
      • If you do not have Thomasville Tomme, Gruyere or Provolone will also work.
    • About ½ cup softened butter, or mayonnaise
    • OPTIONAL: cooked bacon, sliced tomato, fresh spinach, dijon mustard


  1. Preheat oven to 300°F
  2. Lay sliced bread out in opposing halves and top with a layer of Green Hill and then a layer of Thomasville Tomme.
  3. Fold halves on top of each other to form a sandwich. If you are adding additional toppings, go ahead and add these now. Slightly push down on your sandwiches to solidify your ingredients to keep them from spilling out into the pan.
  4. Coat each exterior side of the sandwich bread with a generous slather of either butter or mayonnaise. We prefer using mayonnaise to give it a great texture.
  5. Heat a skillet over medium heat, and put two sandwiches down in the pan and let them sear until you get a beautiful golden crust--- start with lower heat if you are concerned about burning the bread-- and then flip to the other side and repeat.
  6. Once you have a beautiful crust on both sides of your sandwich, transfer them to a baking sheet, and repeat with your remaining sandwiches.
  7. Once you have all your sandwiches seared, you can put them in the oven for 10-15 minutes to heat all the way through.
  8. Cut into one to check that your cheese is melted, if so, serve immediately. If not, put your sandwiches back in the oven for a few more minutes.


From our family to yours, welcome to the herd!

© 2024 Sweet Grass Dairy.